Unexpected Capabilities. Unmatched Service.
a person calculates budget numbers at a desk.

Budgeting 101 for Nonprofits

Think of a nonprofit budget as your mission expressed in dollars. Every item reflects a decision about what communities you’ll serve, which programs you’ll run and the capacity you’ll need to do it well.

It’s also a representation of the mission to key stakeholders. A realistic, carefully assembled budget provides your leadership team with a roadmap, instills confidence in your board of directors and gives donors a reason to trust you with their gifts.

The following is a guide we’ve developed to support nonprofits in their budgeting efforts.

Timing

Before we even get into building the document itself, let’s discuss the “when.”

Typically, nonprofits should begin creating a budget at least three months before the end of the fiscal year. This allows enough time to create and improve multiple drafts of the budget and ensure timely board approval.

Start With Your Strategic Priorities

Many people find that budgeting is easier when it starts with outcomes (such as the number of clients served, workshops delivered or meals provided) and works backward to costs. So before you open a spreadsheet, revisit your strategic plan and program goals.

You’re trying to answer two questions: What will you accomplish next year? And what will it take?

This is something of a precursor to the next step: identifying and categorizing costs. While many expenses are inherent and easy to plug in from one year to the next, understanding what you’re trying to accomplish should also bring to light certain costs that might change from one year to the next.

For instance, if one of your strategic priorities is expanding the number of communities served, you’ll likely need to account for hiring and onboarding costs. If you aim to launch a fresh program every year, you might need to factor in costs such as marketing, donor outreach and possibly new personnel.

Identify and Categorize Costs

Now that you have your strategic priorities in mind, you need to pair that with operational knowledge to put together a full list of your nonprofit’s expenses. In addition to what it’ll take to reach your mission goals, you should also account for things like rent, utilities, IT, accounting and executive leadership.

You can organize all of these costs into three buckets:

  1. Program costs: Any expenses that are directly related to programs that fulfill your mission. For instance, a nonprofit dedicated to wildlife youth education would include the costs of implementing in-school visits, tree plantings and garden webinars in this bucket.
  2. General and administrative (G&A) costs: This is where you put most of your day-to-day costs, such as rent, utilities and salaries.
  3. Fundraising costs: Just like it sounds. Marketing, fundraising software, events and other related costs go into this bucket.

It’s important to note that the bottom two expenses are considered “overhead.” Once upon a time, donors primarily judged nonprofits on their level of overhead, with the logic being that every dollar spent on overhead is a dollar not spent on the mission. But it’s a widely debunked myth; many overhead costs are crucial to nonprofit success.

Estimate Revenue (Conservatively)

Now that you have your costs, it’s time to determine how you’ll pay for them.

Most nonprofit revenue tends to come from the same places:

  • Individual gifts
  • Corporate/institutional philanthropic gifts
  • Government/foundation grants
  • Earned income from fees, merchandise and other sources

Consider Revenue Expectations

Some revenues are more certain than others. For instance, a nonprofit really doesn’t need to worry about the likelihood of receiving revenues tied to a signed grant agreement, but projected first-time event sponsors could be a coin flip to pan out. So it’s also best to bundle your revenues into broad likelihood categories: “committed,” “likely,” “possible” and “unlikely.” Budget committed revenue in full, then reasonably discount the other revenue categories as best you can based on historical data.

You should use this data in scenario planning. This is where you build best-, expected- and worst-case scenarios so you know in advance what you would need to cut or defer if revenue comes in well ahead of, at or under targets.

Separate Restricted and Unrestricted Funds, Too

Not every dollar can go everywhere. Under nonprofit accounting rules, contributions are classified as either with donor restrictions (restricted) or without donor restrictions (unrestricted). For instance, a grant for a youth literacy program can’t cover your general operating shortfall, no matter how tight things get.

Track restricted funds against the programs or purposes they support. This will help your nonprofit:

  • Avoid accidentally spending restricted money on unallowable costs.
  • See how much unrestricted revenue you have for G&A and fundraising.
  • Prepare for grant reporting and audits with clean documentation.

Pay particular attention to timing. A restricted grant may be received in one year but spent over the next. This must be carefully tracked to keep your financial statements accurate.

Involve Program Staff

If you’re a larger nonprofit, your finance team shouldn’t build the budget alone.

Program directors know what it really costs to deliver services: supplies run out early, travel is underestimated, part-time help is needed in the spring. Involving them makes your budget more effective. It not only improves accuracy, but it also creates ownership. After all, people are far more likely to manage a budget they helped write.

Set a clear timeline, give program leaders a simple template and schedule review meetings to reconcile requests with available revenue. You’ll likely face some difficult tradeoffs. Just make sure they’re guided by mission and strategy.

Present the Budget to Your Board

The board of directors’ role is to review and approve the budget, not to build it.

When you present the budget, tell the story behind the numbers. Highlight key assumptions, major changes from the prior year, revenue risks and available reserves. Include a short summary of how the budget supports the strategic plan, along with questions you expect board members to ask.

Directors who understand the “why” behind the figures are better equipped to govern and to advocate for the organization.

Monitor Actuals Year-Round

Budget approval is a checkpoint, not the finish line.

Compare your budget to actual results on a monthly or at least quarterly basis, and investigate meaningful variances. Is a shortfall timing-related or a lasting problem? Is an overage a one-time event or a trend?

Share clear, concise budget-to-actual reports with leadership and the board’s finance committee. If conditions change significantly, such as a lost grant or an unexpected expense, don’t be afraid to reforecast. A budget is a living tool, and adjusting it midyear is a sign of good management, not failure.

Ready to Strengthen Your Nonprofit’s Financial Plan?

A strong budget ensures that your mission remains funded, your board stays informed and your donors keep their confidence. But building a comprehensive budget may be a heavy lift for a lean team.

McManamon & Co. is an accounting, tax, fraud, forensic and consulting firm that serves nonprofits, as well as small and midsize businesses. Our experienced team can help your nonprofit organization with budgeting and forecasting, financial reporting, outsourced accounting and CFO support, so you can focus on your mission with a clear view of your finances.

Call us at 440.892.8900 or contact us online to learn how we can help you build a budget that works.

Tags:  , , , , , , | Posted in McManamon & Co., nonprofit